When your toddler melts down over a minor setback or your school-aged child seems to shift from calm to explosive in seconds, it’s not wilful defiance—it’s biology. Dr. Daniel Siegel’s Upstairs/Downstairs Brain model offers a neuroscience-backed framework that helps parents and educators understand what’s happening in a child’s brain during these moments, and more importantly, how to respond in ways that build resilience and emotional strength.
Comment ‘Blog’ and I’ll send you the link to my site where you can read the full blog with all citations included.
The Brain’s Two Systems: A House Divided
Siegel uses the metaphor of a two-story house to describe how our brains are organized. This simple yet powerful model translates complex neuroscience into something parents can actually understand and apply in real life.
The Downstairs Brain: Built for Survival
The downstairs brain comprises the limbic system and brainstem—the most ancient, evolutionary parts of our brain responsible for survival. This is where you’ll find the amygdala, a almond-shaped structure that acts like your brain’s smoke detector, constantly scanning the environment for threat. When triggered, the downstairs brain activates your fight-flight-freeze response, flooding the body with stress hormones like cortisol and adrenaline to prepare you for danger.
The downstairs brain is fully developed and operational from birth. It’s responsible for:
- Basic functions like breathing and heart rate regulation
- Processing emotions and detecting threat
- Driving impulsive reactions and survival instincts
- The immediate “I need to react NOW” response
In young children, this system is powerful and ready to protect them. The problem? Without the balancing influence of the thinking brain, it’s also prone to overreaction.
The Upstairs Brain: Where Thinking Lives
The upstairs brain is centered in the prefrontal cortex—the brain region behind your forehead that’s responsible for everything we think of as “being good at being human.” This is where you’ll find:
- Planning and decision-making
- Problem-solving and reasoning
- Empathy and perspective-taking
- Impulse control and emotional regulation
- Moral reasoning and reflection
- The ability to think before acting
The upstairs brain is what allows us to consider consequences, understand how our actions affect others, and choose responses rather than simply react. It’s sophisticated, flexible, and absolutely essential for healthy emotional and social development.
Here’s the catch: the upstairs brain is still under construction until approximately the mid-twenties, with significant development continuing through adolescence. In young children, this crucial system is only partially online, which explains why asking a dysregulated three-year-old to “use your words” or “think about how that made them feel” often falls flat. They literally can’t access those capabilities in the moment.
When the Downstairs Brain Takes Over: The Amygdala Hijack
Between the upstairs and downstairs brain is a metaphorical staircase that allows information to flow between these systems, integrating our emotions with our thinking. When all is well, this staircase functions smoothly—the upstairs brain monitors and can calm the powerful reactions of the downstairs brain, creating flexibility and thoughtful responses.
But when a child becomes overwhelmed by strong emotion, stress, or fear, something shifts. The amygdala becomes hyperactivated, and what researchers call an “amygdala hijack” occurs. In children, this often manifests as what parents recognize as a meltdown or tantrum.
During an amygdala hijack, the sheer intensity of emotional activation in the downstairs brain temporarily closes a “baby gate” at the bottom of the stairs, restricting the child’s access to their upstairs brain functions. This isn’t a choice or a behavior problem—it’s a neurological limitation. The child has become trapped downstairs, unable to access reasoning, empathy, or any of the self-regulation skills they might demonstrate when calm.
The physical symptoms during an amygdala hijack are unmistakable:
- Increased heart rate and blood pressure
- Racing thoughts or mental confusion
- Sudden emotional intensity (rage, terror, despair)
- Physical tension or explosive movement
- Difficulty understanding or processing words
- Loss of access to logical thinking
This state can last seconds or much longer, and importantly, it’s not something the child can simply “snap out of” through willpower or logic. Telling a child in an amygdala hijack to “calm down” or “stop crying” is like asking them to manually slow their racing heart—neurologically impossible in that moment.
Why Some Children Hijack More Easily
Not all children flip their lids with equal frequency. Research shows that certain conditions make an amygdala hijack more likely, including:
- Hunger or fatigue
- Overstimulation from the environment
- Lack of sleep
- Accumulated stress
- Triggering an emotional button (something with personal significance)
- Previous trauma or adverse experiences
Children who have experienced early adversity show particular vulnerability. Traumatic experiences can sensitize the amygdala’s reactivity, meaning the threshold for what triggers an emotional response becomes lower. A child who experienced neglect, abuse, or significant stress in infancy may find their amygdala firing in response to everyday stressors that wouldn’t bother another child—not because they’re “difficult,” but because their neurological system has learned that the world is unsafe and threats abound.
The Path Forward: Integration and Co-Regulation
Understanding the Upstairs/Downstairs Brain model shifts how we respond to children’s big emotions. Instead of viewing dysregulation as misbehavior requiring punishment, we can see it as a developmental moment—an opportunity to help build the very architecture the child needs for lifelong emotional health.
Building the Staircase
The goal isn’t to eliminate the downstairs brain or rush the development of the upstairs brain. Instead, parents and caregivers work to strengthen the connections between these systems—to build and reinforce that metaphorical staircase. This integration develops through repeated, positive experiences with co-regulation.
Co-regulation is the process through which a child learns self-regulation skills by interacting with a calm, trusted adult. When you remain calm and present during a child’s distress, you’re literally providing external regulation—using your own developed upstairs brain to help soothe their hyperactive downstairs brain.
Over time, with consistent co-regulation, something remarkable happens: the child’s nervous system learns that intense emotion is survivable, that comfort is available, and that their brain can return to baseline after distress. These repeated experiences rewire the neural connections between the upstairs and downstairs brain, gradually making it easier for the child to access their thinking brain, even during challenging emotions.
Three Powerful Strategies
Research on brain integration suggests several evidence-based approaches that work across childhood:
1. Connect First, Redirect Later
When your child is in emotional distress, the logical left brain is offline. Your job isn’t immediately to teach, correct, or explain. Instead, connect emotionally first by using your own calm presence, warmth, and attuned attention. This right-brain-to-right-brain connection (using the emotional/intuitive parts of both brains) helps the child feel felt and heard, which gradually helps their nervous system settle.
Only once the child has calmed somewhat should you shift to the “redirect” phase—introducing logic, problem-solving, and discussion of consequences. This two-step approach respects the neurobiology of emotion regulation rather than fighting against it.
2. Name It to Tame It
The act of putting feelings into words activates the left brain’s organizing, logical systems and helps integrate right-brain emotions into a coherent narrative. When you help children name their feelings—”You’re feeling really frustrated that the tower fell down,” or “It seems like you’re scared about starting school”—you’re doing crucial brain-building work.
Naming emotions:
- Reduces confusion and fear by giving shape to overwhelming internal states
- Strengthens emotional regulation by engaging the thinking brain
- Helps children understand that all feelings are valid and manageable
- Builds the foundation for self-awareness and resilience
Start with simple feelings words (sad, happy, angry, scared) in the early years, gradually extending vocabulary as children mature.
3. Exercise the Upstairs Brain Through Experience
Just as muscles strengthen through use, the upstairs brain develops through practice. Intentionally giving children opportunities to use their thinking brain—through decision-making, discussing emotions, playing “what would you do if?” games, reading stories about characters managing feelings, and having conversations about morality and empathy—helps build and strengthen these neural pathways.
The Role of Secure Attachment
Underlying all of these strategies is something foundational: secure attachment. Research consistently shows that children who experience responsive, warm, emotionally available caregiving develop stronger neural connections supporting emotion regulation and resilience.
When a parent consistently responds to a child’s cues with sensitivity and care, they’re not just soothing the child in the moment. They’re literally shaping the architecture of the child’s developing brain, creating stronger links between the downstairs and upstairs systems, and building a nervous system that can handle stress more flexibly.
Moving Beyond “Bad Behavior”
The Upstairs/Downstairs Brain model fundamentally reframes how we understand childhood behavior challenges. A meltdown isn’t evidence of a spoiled or willful child. It’s not a failure of discipline or parenting. It’s biology—a child whose developing brain is doing exactly what it’s designed to do when overwhelmed.
This doesn’t mean anything goes. Children still need boundaries, consistency, and clear expectations. But when we understand the why behind the behavior, we can respond with compassion and wisdom rather than frustration and punishment.
When you see it this way, you can respond by:
- Remaining calm and present, using your mature nervous system to help regulate theirs
- Validating the feelings (“You’re really upset”) while maintaining the limit (“And we don’t hit”)
- Waiting until the child has calmed to discuss what happened and problem-solve together
- Recognizing that teaching moments after dysregulation are far more effective than in-the-moment lectures
- Celebrating small improvements in emotional regulation as the significant developmental achievements they truly are
Every time you handle a child’s big emotion with compassion and co-regulation rather than punishment and shame, you’re quite literally building new neural pathways. You’re strengthening that staircase between downstairs and upstairs, teaching their nervous system that they can handle big feelings, and modeling what healthy emotional regulation looks like.
This is the long game of parenting—and it’s where the science shows profound, lasting change happens.
References
Siegel, D. J., & Bryson, T. P. (2012). The Whole-Brain Child: 12 Revolutionary Strategies to Nurture Your Child’s Developing Mind. Bantam.
The Upstairs and Downstairs of the Brain: Part One. (2023, August 21). Kids That Go. Retrieved from https://kidsthatgo.com/upstairs-and-downstairs-brain-part-one/
Martin, R. E., et al. (2004). The Neuroscience of Emotion Regulation Development. PubMed Central. Retrieved from https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC5096655/
Understanding the “upstairs” and “downstairs” brain. (2016, January 4). Michigan State University Extension. Retrieved from https://www.canr.msu.edu/news/understanding_the_upstairs_and_downstairs_brain
Healthline. (2019). Amygdala Hijack: When Emotion Takes Over. Retrieved from https://www.healthline.com/health/stress/amygdala-hijack
Building our Children’s Developing Brain. (2020). SET Trust. Retrieved from https://setrust.hscni.net/wp-content/uploads/2020/08/Building-Our-Childs-Developing-Brain-V4-1.pdf
Simply Psychology. (2025, July 8). When Does the Prefrontal Cortex Fully Develop? Retrieved from https://www.simplypsychology.org/prefrontal-cortex-development-age.html
Kolk, S. M. (2021). Development of prefrontal cortex. Nature, 58(10), 1137–1147.
Gozen. (2018, November 14). Stop the Amygdala Hijack in its Tracks. Retrieved from https://gozen.com/stop-the-amygdala-hijack-in-its-tracks/
Eden Futures. (2024). Amygdala Hijack: How It Works, Signs, & How To Cope. Retrieved from https://edenfutures.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/07/Amygdala-Hijack-How-It-Works-Signs-amp-How-To-Cope.pdf
Dr. Dan Siegel’s Hand Model of the Brain. (2022, September 5). YouTube. Retrieved from https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LdaUZ_wbD1c
Reframing Autism. (2025, July 17). Emotional Regulation, Part One: What is it and Why is it so Hard? Retrieved from https://reframingautism.org.au/emotional-regulation-part-one-what-is-it-and-why-is-it-so-hard/
Occupational Therapy Australia. (2023, October 18). Co-Regulation. Retrieved from https://occupationaltherapy.com.au/co-regulation/
ED Parenting. (2025, August 11). How to Co-Regulate with Your Highly Sensitive Child. Retrieved from https://www.edparenting.com/blog/co-regulation-strategies-for-parents-of-highly-sensitive-children
An Introduction to Mindsight with Dr. Dan Siegel. (2016, November 20). TeachKat. Retrieved from https://teachkat.wordpress.com/2016/11/20/an-introduction-to-integrating-the-brain-with-dr-dan-siegel/
Chapter 2 – The Whole-Brain Child. (2025, June 14). YouTube. Retrieved from https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SF3Jlrnuz3U
The Act Group. (2025, November 17). Helping Children Name Their Feelings: How Language Creates Safety and Emotional Security. Retrieved from https://theactgroup.com.au/helping-children-name-their-feelings-how-language-creates-safety-and-emotional-security/
Australian Institute of Family Studies. (2014, September 30). Developmental Differences in Children Who Have Experienced Adversity: Guide No.1. Retrieved from https://aifs.gov.au/resources/practice-guides/developmental-differences-children-who-have-experienced-adversity-guide-no1
Parenting Science. (2025). Secure Attachment Relationships Protect Kids from Toxic Stress. Retrieved from https://parentingscience.com/secure-attachment-relationships/
Frosch, C. A. (2019). Parenting and Child Development: A Relational Health Perspective. PubMed Central. Retrieved from https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7781063/
Birth to 5 Matters. (2020, October 31). Self-Regulation. Retrieved from https://birthto5matters.org.uk/self-regulation/
Lobo, F. M., et al. (2020). Understanding the Parent-Child Coregulation Patterns. PubMed Central. Retrieved from https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7556995/
